Tuesday, June 2, 2009

Happy Fucking Birthday

A good name is better than a good ointment, And the day of one's death is better than the day of one's birth. - Ecclesiastes 7:1

I'm thirty four years old today. I want to scream. This birthday is exposing unhealed, fractured grief; I can't even write the words I want to say. Not right, anyway. Everything aches. There is something unnatural about being as old as your big sister. It's simply eerie and wrong. I feel monstrous. Too many years lived. Too many years to go. I don't want to breathe another minute. Using up better people's air.


All weekend long, I felt it coming. I've been like an animal sensing the earthquake, precognitive, ears twitching, the tastes of catastrophe on the wind and on my tongue. I felt like there were all these gaping holes inside me. I couldn't get enough to eat; I behaved like a starving person. It's unusual for me to binge but I didn't know what else to do. Eat. Eat. Vomit. I'm so gross. I'm 34 years old and this is what I am. I can't even look in the mirror without feeling like I need to be sick. I don't want to eat another bite of food. Using up better people's food. Taking up better people's space with this...pathetic, waste of a body.

God got it all wrong. I shouldn't be alive. I keep thinking someone is going to realize there was a mistake; tap, tap, tap at my door. "Excuse me, ma'am, but you're going to have to come with us now. We're terribly sorry to have to tell you this but you're dead. Amy is alive."

I'd tell whoever it was not to be terribly sorry. I'd say, "Finally. I don't have to go on living this lie." I'd gladly give up my spot in this world, that space I so pathetically and pointlessly occupy, so that Amy could have one more minute, one more day dispensing her precious gifts, her bright and numerous smiles, her sweet "hello theres" to passersby, her homemade whipped cream, her corny jokes that made me roll my eyes.

God, she was so fucking beautiful. Look at her.





The pretty sister. I knew that. It was a hard, bitter pill to swallow but I had finally gotten it down. She was beautiful and I was not and I was finally okay with the knowledge of that. And then she got cancer. And then she lost her hair, her long, thick auburn hair. Slowly, ever slowly, her beauty started to fade. And deep down inside me, in those dark and wicked places inside myself, I felt glad to be prettier. See what I am? Terrible.

Some things have a lovely way of dying. Roses come to mind. I have three dying roses hanging from the blinds in my kitchen. As they die, their colors deepen and their skins soften first and then turn crisp. Those roses look better when they're dying than when they were alive. Not people. I hate to think of Amy in those last days on hospice. Completely bald, a pallor of yellow. It felt like everything went yellow about her. Skin, eyes, teeth. And I thought of the way she loved yellow roses and it made me sad beyond what I can name with words. I tried to think of her like that, though: A yellow rose. My memories of her like dried rose petals in a ceramic dish on the coffee table.

A month before she died, Amy had picked out photos of herself for her funeral collage. The pictures were the way she wanted to be remembered. That last week, I must have looked through those pictures a thousand times. I must have showed them to every person who came through the door to say their goodbyes. I was really trying to tell them how to remember her: not as the bald, yellow shell of a person mumbling in the bed but as the vibrant, beautiful woman she was just a few years before. I even made the hospice nurse look at the pictures. I know she was rolling her eyes internally but I didn't care. I wanted her to know what Amy had been. I wanted her to know that she had been beautiful. I don't know why that mattered so much to me. After years of envying her beauty, of hating her for it, it was the suddenly the only thing I wanted people to know about her.

How must it have felt to pick out photos for your own funeral collage? How must it have felt to know that 34 years was all you were going to get? I know my sister wouldn't be looking at her life the way I do mine, with contempt and utter despair. I can read your mind. You are thinking I need to suck it up and get over my shit. I need to appreciate what I've been given and stop being a whiny little bitch about the things I've lost. I wish I could do that.

Since I was raised a Jehovah's Witness, we didn't celebrate birthdays when I was growing up. Your birthday came and it was just like any other day. We didn't have parties or presents or singing or blowing out candles on a cake. When other children celebrated their birthdays at school with cupcakes, I had to sit outside in the hallway until the festivities were over. I remember sitting out in the empty, lonely hallway listening to the sounds of all the kids laughing and eating their treats and enjoying being a part of something. They were a part of somebody's special day. And they knew that one day soon, it would be their turn to be special too. It was so painful for me to be excluded. I always felt like I was being punished for...being alive. I knew my special day would never come. I knew that there would only be more days of sitting alone in an empty hallway, my butt going numb on the hard floor, eavesdropping on other people's joy.

And that's still true for me, for my life. I can never really get in it, feel happy, feel special. It doesn't belong to me. It never has. Happy 34th Birthday to me. It feels hollow and weird. I'm afraid that it always will. I wish I knew how Amy managed to find joy in the life that was handed to her. If she was here, right now, I would ask her to tell me those secrets. I would ask her to give me those instructions on how to smile from ear to ear and actually mean it. I would ask her to tell me how to laugh with abandon from the deepest core of my soul. I would ask her how I will survive being 34 when she didn't. I would ask her if 34 years was enough.

18 comments:

  1. Dearest Gwen, I am so very sorry for your pain. Having lost my lover to cancer 21 months ago I am in the unenviable position of understanding what you are going through.

    Your sister was indeed extremely beautiful. I hope you have many wonderful memories to help sustain you in this dark time.

    There's nothing I can say to make you feel better but I hope it helps in some small way to know that someone on the other side of the world is thinking of you and of Amy right now

    ReplyDelete
  2. Happy Birthday, fellow Gemini.

    Birthdays were never a big deal growing up for me either, but my wife had a very different perspective: your birthday isn't for you, it's a day for the people that love you to celebrate the fact that you were born and came into their lives. So, today isn't so much about you as it is your daughter and husband and family.

    That doesn't take the pain away. Nothing can change the fact that you're as old as Amy was. I have no remedy for that, as I am sure you understand.

    I am sorry you are suffering right now. I really don't know what else to say.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nurse Myra - Thanks for your sympathetic words. I'm sorry that you are able to understand, that you know how it feels to lose a sister. I lost my sister about 21 months ago, too.

    Sci Fi Dad - Ah, a fellow Gemini. So do you have a dual personality, too? That's an interesting way of looking at birthdays. I admit I had never considered that it mattered to others. Thanks so much for your comment.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I bet your sister would celebrate your ability to see and feel these things and also get you through them and on to living well and completely without regret. She would want you to keep growing WITH her, take her with you through the birthdays. Make birthdays GOOD. Living well is a tribute to you and her!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Gwen, I'm sorry you're having such a hard time. My impulse is to say that you can still ask your sister all of those questions. You might even get answers.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Holy shit--you are echoing exactly how I feel. I've often felt like I was the one who should have died and my husband should be alive. I think he wouldn't have made such a mess of things the way I have. That my son would his best friend and I wouldn't worry about my daughter's future relationships with men because she's growing up without a father.

    It completely suck

    And watching him die was horrid. My son still talks about when Daddy was in the wheelchair or when daddy had his cane or his walker.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Your sister was very beautiful, but you are beautiful too. Don't forget that. And try to have a happy birthday because you deserve it.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Happy birthday! You have talent, and beauty, and it's veritable. I'm sorry only because you believe otherwise.

    ReplyDelete
  9. If I were the internet hugs type, I'd offer you one. Instead, I'll wish you a happy birthday, and hope that you can find the happy in it, despite the loss of your sister.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I have decided that you are going to be happy from now on, and there's nothing you can do about it. So there.

    ReplyDelete
  11. My mom died when I was 11 months old. I was her only child. So, as my own first child's 11th month approached, I got really scared. Regardless of the fact that the circumstances were entirely different, there was that feeling that my son, that I, would relive the same fate.

    My wife is still here. My son is 15.

    We live on, my friend . . .

    ReplyDelete
  12. Oh Gwen
    I cannot even begin to imagine the horror. Your beloved sister was LOVELY. Beautiful. But you are so beautiful, too. The fact that you think only of her tells me what a gorgeous heart and mind you have. I meant it when I said you were cute and sweet. I'll never forget meeting you.

    I wish I had the words to make you feel peace, at least. Or That you don't have to live this torment anymore.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Much love to you my little weeping willow. Keep weeping as long as you need. In the meantime? You can shove all the 'look at me, not my sister photos' in front of me that you want, and I'll still be focused on the fact that you're pretty and it's your birthday. Happy birthday to youuuuuuuuu...xoxo

    ReplyDelete
  14. Growing up, my best friend and her "big" sister, Liz, (not quite two years older than us) were the closest things I had to sisters.

    I have a wonderful family. But I can't ever remember not being a part of their family, too.

    When Liz died in a car accident in 2001 at the age of 29, I felt like I'd lost a limb. Or an organ. Like there this gaping hole in the world. I wasn't sure how to function. How to think. I think what kept me going in the beginning was the need to be there for her "real" sister and her mom.

    After the shock and anger and numbness faded, I felt just this terrible WRONGNESS for so long. This sense that this was NOT how it was supposed to happen. Some big cosmic mistake.

    I'd like to say that I think of her every year on the anniversaries of her birth and her death. But the truth is that I still think of her so much more often than that.

    She might not have been my biological sister, but I understand the survival guilt and pain.

    But I don't feel that way anymore. I don't know how or when I got here, exactly, but I'm in a place where I can accept her death now.

    It gets just a little easier with time. Instead of sharp daggers, the pain becomes like a rough blanket. As long as you don't wrap yourself in it, you feel like you can survive it when it brushes up against you at unexpected moments.

    I can't tell you some magic trick or show you some easy path to get to the other side of the canyon of your grief and loss.

    But I CAN stand here on the other side and tell you that it IS possible to get here. And that it's a better place to be. I hope you can join us over here when you are ready.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Birthdays can be a hard thing, especially if you do not see yourself as other people do.

    I'm sorry for your sister. She sounds like a lovely person. However, you are too and were put here for a reason.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Christ, you break my heart, you know that? These words, these feelings, they are powerful and real and terrible in their very humanness. We are at once fragile and sturdy things, aren't we?

    Much love to you on your birthday, even though I missed it. And I will dictate, like Rassles, that you be happy henceforth.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This post made me SOB. My heart actually hurts.
    *sending lots of good vibes from an internet stranger*

    ReplyDelete
  18. So, whether you like it or not - Happy Birthday. I don't celebrate birthdays much, my own anyway, because it's just another day. But from reading this post, you need to. You deserve to celebrate. You owe yourself a celebration.

    ReplyDelete